Magic: The Gathering foils curl because the card is a laminate of a metal foil layer glued to paper stock, and only the paper responds to humidity. When the air is dry the paper shrinks and the card arches with the foil face bowing outward; when the air is damp the paper swells and the card cups the other way. The fix is to put the paper back where it was when the card was printed, about 60 to 65 percent relative humidity, slowly, and then hold the card flat while it settles. Here is how to do that without wrecking a $500 card, and how to store foils so you never have to do it twice.
Figures last checked Oct 29, 2026.
Why do Magic foils curl?
A foil Magic card has three layers: the foil face, the adhesive, and the cardboard behind it. MTGGoldfish's Tawnos's Toolbox (May 8, 2021) measured the cardboard's moisture content at printing at roughly 60 to 65 percent and showed what happens on either side of that: in a desiccant container, half the test cards had fully arched within 12 hours; at 100 percent humidity, arched cards took 48 hours to come back and ended up slightly cupped. The foil layer and the paper layer want to be different sizes at any humidity other than the one they were bonded at, and the card bends toward whichever side is smaller. Star City Games (March 24, 2021) adds that heat and cold make the metal layer expand and contract too, which is why a foil left in a car does worse than one left in a closet.
Nonfoil cards are two printed paper faces around a blue core, all paper, so the layers move together. They can still warp from bad storage, but they do not fight themselves.
Some sets are worse than others. Star City Games names Commander Legends as the peak of the problem, and the foil only Nexus of Fate promo warped badly enough that judges had to proxy it at Pro Tour 25th Anniversary. The problem has not gone away with premium treatments. MTG Rocks noted on June 1, 2023 that the preview image of the 1 of 1 serialized The One Ring already appeared to be curled, though that was never confirmed. Every chase foil in the Universes Beyond price hub is a laminate of this kind, and the more expensive the card the more it matters that you handle the fix correctly.
Which way is your foil curled?
Look at the card from the front. If the left and right edges curl away from you, so the foil face is convex, the paper has dried out and shrunk. That is arching, and it is the common case in a heated house in winter, where MTGPrice (Jan 27, 2021) notes forced air heat can push indoor humidity below 30 percent. The card needs moisture. If the edges curl toward you, so the foil face is concave, the paper has absorbed moisture and swelled. That is cupping, typical of a basement or a humid summer, and the card needs to dry out. The two fixes are opposite, so check the direction before you do anything.
How do you flatten an arched foil without damage?
The method below is the one Draftsim (updated Aug 28, 2026) and MTGPrice both describe, and it works because it adds humidity through the air rather than through contact. Nothing wet ever touches the card.
- Take a clear, airtight plastic container with a lid. Lightly dampen a paper towel, wring it until it does not drip, and lay it flat on the bottom.
- Put a raised platform in the container so the card sits above the towel with air on all sides. Draftsim uses upside down silicone cupcake molds; MTGPrice uses a pencil case lid. The card goes on the platform with the bowed side facing up.
- Close the lid and wait 30 minutes. Check the card. You are looking for it to be slightly wavy, about halfway back from arched, not flat. If it is still fully arched, give it another 30 minutes. MTGPrice reports never needing more than 60 minutes total.
- Watch for condensation on the lid. If drops form, open the container and wipe it. Water dripping onto the foil will mark it.
- Take the card out and let it sit in open air for about 10 minutes so the surface is dry and the card acclimates.
- Sleeve it and put it under a heavy book overnight. In the morning it should be flat.
If the card comes out of the container curled toward you, you overdid it. Let it air out until it is wavy again, then press it. For large batches, MTGPrice suggests a cigar humidor pack in place of the paper towel and a wait of a day or two, which is gentler and more even. Whichever way you do it, test the method on a few commons from the same set first. A foil common from Final Fantasy behaves the same as a surge foil Sephiroth and costs almost nothing.
How do you fix a foil that curls the other way?
A cupped card has too much moisture, so the container gets a two way humidity control pack instead of a wet towel. Draftsim recommends a pack rated for 55 to 65 percent, which costs $10 to $20, and simply storing the card in a closed box with the pack until it relaxes. This takes longer than rehydrating, hours to a day or two depending on how far gone the card is. Do not use a desiccant packet or a dry heat source. The MTGGoldfish test shows desiccant arches a card in under 12 hours, and you will overshoot straight from cupped to arched.
What humidity should Magic foils be stored at?
55 percent, give or take. In the MTGGoldfish test, cards stored with 55 percent humidity packs for about a month changed the least. At 62 percent, older foils cupped slightly while Commander Legends and Time Spiral Remastered foils became mildly arched. At 72 percent, every card cupped. Draftsim lands on the same target and suggests a size 8 two way pack, which fits inside a deck box. A cheap digital hygrometer in the room where you keep the cards tells you whether you need to do anything at all. If the room sits between 50 and 60 percent year round, most foils will stay flat without help.
| Storage humidity | What happened to foils over about a month (MTGGoldfish, May 2021) |
|---|---|
| Desiccant (near 0%) | Half the cards fully arched within 12 hours |
| 55% | Least change of any condition tested |
| 62% | Older foils cupped slightly; Commander Legends and Time Spiral Remastered foils mildly arched |
| 72% | All cards cupped |
| 100% | Arched cards flattened in 48 hours, then went slightly cupped |
Does rigid storage stop foils from curling?
Mostly. The same MTGGoldfish test compared sleeved cards in a desiccant container and found a single sleeve gave minimal protection while double sleeving held up much better, because the inner perfect fit sleeve slows moisture exchange. A rigid holder goes one step further: it does not change the humidity, but it stops the card from taking a set while the humidity moves. MTGPrice's prevention advice is exactly that stack, perfect fit sleeve, penny sleeve, hard toploader. A magnetic holder like an Ultra PRO ONE-TOUCH does the same job with a tighter fit, and a card kept in one fits the CardBlx One Touch Case, which keeps dust and handling off it while the holder keeps it flat. A card in a Zion MagPro fits the CardBlx MagPro Case the same way.
Two things rigid storage does not fix. First, a card that is already arched should be flattened before it goes into a tight holder; forcing a curled foil into a one touch puts stress on the corners and the holder will not fully flatten it anyway. Second, a frame on a wall is not rigid storage. Framed foils sit against glass on one side and open air on the other, in a room whose humidity swings with the seasons, and they curl inside the frame. If you want a chase foil on display, put it in a holder first and then on a stand. The general approach is in how to display graded cards, and the grading question itself, which removes the curling problem entirely once the card is in a slab, is covered in which Magic cards are worth grading.
What would I do with a curled chase foil?
If it is a $5 foil, fix it with the container method and move on. If it is a surge foil Sephiroth or a cosmic foil Soul Stone, I would still fix it, because graders note warping and a visibly curled card will not get a 10, but I would use the humidor pack version over two days rather than the paper towel version over an hour. Slower is safer and the card is not going anywhere. Then it goes straight into a perfect fit sleeve, a magnetic holder and a box with a 55 percent pack, and it does not come out again until it ships to the grader. One more caution: a card that fails the light test or the weight check in how to tell if a Magic card is fake will not behave like a real foil in a humidity chamber either, because counterfeit stock is usually a single plastic coated sheet. If the method does nothing after two hours, that is worth noticing.
Magic: The Gathering is a trademark of Wizards of the Coast. CardBlx is an independent brand and is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast.