Which Magic: The Gathering Cards Are Worth Grading (and PSA vs CGC vs BGS for Magic)

|Rob Pollock

A Magic: The Gathering card is worth grading when a top grade sells for clearly more than the raw card plus about $60 to $80 in fees, three to five months of waiting, and the real chance it comes back a 9. By that test, almost every Collector Booster headliner qualifies (a PSA 10 gleaming gold Smaug sold for $53,499.69 on eBay on Oct 4, 2026 against raw sales around $20,000), serialized cards usually qualify, and the mass graded Final Fantasy mythics mostly do not (a PSA 10 Tifa Lockhart was worth about $210 as of June 2026 with more than 1,000 copies already slabbed). Below: the current fees and turnaround at PSA, CGC and BGS, the population numbers that matter for Magic, dated examples of what a 10 adds, and which grader I would send a given card to.

Fees, turnaround and prices last checked Oct 29, 2026. Grader fees change every few months in 2026 and two of the three companies have paused tiers this year, so confirm on the grader's own site the week you submit.

What do PSA, CGC and BGS charge to grade a Magic card in 2026?

Grader and tier Fee per card Max declared value Estimated turnaround Status and source
PSA Standard $59.99 $1,000 90 to 100 business days Open; PSA notice, Sept 9, 2026
PSA Priority $79.99 $1,500 70 to 80 business days Open; PSA notice, Sept 9, 2026
PSA Express $199 $2,500 20 to 30 business days Open; PSA notice, Sept 9, 2026
PSA Super Express $349 $5,000 Not stated in PSA's notice Open per CardGrade (Oct 16, 2026) and Misprint (June 4, 2026); not listed in PSA's Sept 9 notice
PSA Premier $599 $10,000 7 to 10 business days Open; PSA notice, Sept 9, 2026
PSA Value Bulk, Value, Value Plus, Value Max $24.99 to $64.99 $500 to $1,000 Not applicable Paused since June 2, 2026 (Sports Illustrated, July 1, 2026); "Value tiers remain paused" per PSA, Sept 9, 2026
CGC Bulk $17 Not published on fee notice Not published Effective March 24, 2026; CGC
CGC Economy $20 Not published on fee notice Not published Effective March 24, 2026; CGC
CGC Standard / Express / WalkThrough $55 / $100 / $300 Not published on fee notice Not published Effective Jan 6, 2026; CGC
BGS Base $17.95 (reported, PreGradeCards and The Card Shop Finder) Not published 45 or more business days (beckett.com) New online submissions paused since Aug 5, 2026 per Beckett's availability page, still showing paused Oct 29, 2026
BGS Standard $34.95 (reported, same sources) Not published 20 to 25 business days (beckett.com) Paused with Base
BGS Express / Priority Not published on beckett.com Not published 7 to 10 / 2 to 3 business days (beckett.com) Open per Beckett's availability page

PSA's structure changed on Sept 14, 2026, when it introduced the $59.99 Standard tier, renamed Regular to Priority and raised Express to $199. That comes straight from PSA's own notice dated Sept 9, 2026, which lists Standard, Priority, Express and Premier with the fees and turnarounds in the table; PreGradeCards and CardGrade report the same figures. Super Express is not in that notice, so its $349 fee is the third party figure. PSA requires a Collectors Club membership to submit (about $99 a year per Misprint, June 4, 2026). The four Value tiers have been closed since June 2, 2026 because of a backlog that peaked near 14 million cards; PSA's Sept 9 notice says they remain paused and will reopen in phases, and CardGrade reported 8.2 million cards in the backlog as of Oct 6, 2026. CGC's bulk and economy fees come from its own notices (March 10, 2026 and Dec 9, 2025) and CGC requires no membership. Beckett paused new online Base and Standard submissions on Aug 5, 2026, and its availability page still said paused when I checked it today. Trade press reported a brief reopening in mid September and a second pause on Sept 26 (The Card Shop Finder, Sept 29, 2026), so check that page before you mail anything.

The practical version: the cheapest open path for a card under $1,000 is CGC Economy at $20 or PSA Standard at $59.99 with a three to five month wait. For a card over $2,500, PSA Super Express at $349 or Premier at $599 is the only way to get it back inside a month, and on a $20,000 card that fee is noise.

How many Magic cards have already been graded?

Population is the number that decides whether a 10 is worth anything, and for modern Magic it is already large. Misprint's June 8, 2026 snapshot of combined PSA and CGC populations lists The One Ring (its most slabbed foil printing alone) at about 1,251, Tifa Lockhart at 1,057, Sephiroth, Fabled SOLDIER at 910, Aerith Gainsborough at 857, Cloud, Midgar Mercenary at 736, Yuna at 519, Buster Sword at 452 and Traveling Chocobo at 369. Alpha Black Lotus, by comparison, sits at about 97 combined with zero PSA 10s. Beckett's cross grader figures for Spider-Man (BGS, CGC, PSA and SGC combined, mid 2026) show the same shape: the regular Soul Stone #0066 at 493 graded with a 42.8 percent gem rate, the borderless Gauntlet #0243 at 432 with 20.4 percent, and the cosmic foil #0242 at just 52 with a 90.4 percent gem rate.

Two things follow. First, a gem rate near 90 percent on the cosmic foil means grading it is nearly risk free: Collector Booster headliners come out of the pack clean and the holders cut well. Second, a 20 percent gem rate on the Gauntlet Soul Stone means four out of five submissions come back a 9 or lower, and a 9 on a $1,788 card (PriceCharting guide, Oct 29, 2026) is not a win after fees. The graders do not publish gem rates for every Magic card, so for a card not listed above I would pull the PSA and CGC population pages myself before paying anything.

What does a PSA 10 actually add to a Magic card?

These are real transactions, not guide estimates, from PriceCharting's sales records.

Card Raw sale Top grade sale What the grade added
Smaug the Magnificent, gleaming gold #0249 (The Hobbit) $20,000, TCGplayer, Sept 14, 2026 PSA 10: $53,499.69, eBay, Oct 4, 2026. BGS 9.5: $18,910, Goldin, Oct 18, 2026 A 10 more than doubled it; a 9.5 sold for less than raw
The Soul Stone, cosmic foil #0242 (Spider-Man) $11,000 (eBay, Apr 10, 2026) to $24,000 (TCGplayer, Jan 1, 2026) CGC Pristine 10: $60,000, eBay, June 21, 2026. PSA 10: $35,000, eBay, Dec 19, 2025. BGS 9.5: $32,130, Goldin, May 18, 2026 Two to five times raw depending on grade and grader
Leonardo, Sewer Samurai, Eastman signature #0301 (TMNT) $3,200, TCGplayer, Sept 30, 2026 PSA 10: $5,000, eBay, May 25, 2026 About $1,800, or 56 percent
Mox Jasper, serialized #0419 (Tarkir: Dragonstorm) $2,899.99, TCGplayer, Sept 11, 2026 PSA 10 (252/500): $3,305, eBay, June 12, 2026 About $400, or 14 percent
Emrakul, the World Anew, serialized #0381 (MH3) $1,940.11 guide, PriceCharting, Oct 29, 2026 PSA 10: $2,949.99, March 1, 2026 About $1,000, or 52 percent
Sephiroth, Fabled SOLDIER, borderless surge foil #0527 (Final Fantasy) $840.94 guide, Oct 29, 2026 PSA 10: $1,250 guide, Oct 29, 2026 About $400, or 49 percent
Buster Sword, borderless foil #0351 (Final Fantasy) $169.94 guide, Oct 29, 2026 PSA 10: $304.99 guide. PSA 9: $150.62 guide A 10 adds $135; a 9 loses money
Vivi Ornitier, borderless foil #0321 (Final Fantasy) $180.99 guide, Oct 29, 2026 PSA 10: $250 guide. PSA 9: $194 guide A 10 adds $69, which does not cover a PSA fee

The pattern is the one TCGTalk found across a wider sample in April 2026: the multiple a 10 earns shrinks as the raw price rises, but the dollar gain grows, and the dollar gain is what you are weighing against the fee. On a $180 Vivi the best case is $69 and the 9 case is a loss. On a $20,000 Smaug the 10 case is $33,000 and the 9.5 case is still a $20,000 card. That asymmetry is why every headliner in the Universes Beyond price hub trades mostly in slabs and why the regular mythics underneath them mostly do not.

Which Magic cards are worth grading, then?

Grade it if the raw card is worth more than about $300, it came out of a Collector Booster in the last 18 months, and fewer than a few hundred copies are in the population. That covers the serialized headliners (every card in the serialized master list from Innistrad Remastered onward), the surge foil and textured foil Universes Beyond mythics, and the unnumbered headliners. Grade it regardless of price if it is a serialized card you plan to sell, because the slab is also the authentication, and the number on the label is what buyers search for. Grade vintage only when a 7 or 8 still clears the fee; Alpha and Beta rares qualify, Revised duals in played condition mostly do not.

Do not grade regular frame Final Fantasy or Spider-Man mythics hoping for a PSA 10 flip. The populations passed 1,000 within a year, a 10 is typically worth $100 to $300 (Tifa about $210, Aerith about $186, Buster Sword about $118 per Misprint, June 2026), and the wait is 90 business days at the cheapest open PSA tier. Do not grade a foil that is visibly curled; flatten it first using the method in why Magic foils curl and how to flatten them, because warping costs a grade. And do not grade anything you have not run through the checks in how to tell if a Magic card is fake; a grader will catch a counterfeit, but you will have paid the fee and shipping to learn it.

PSA vs CGC vs BGS: which grader should you use for Magic?

PSA for anything you intend to sell, CGC for anything you intend to keep or that is a misprint, and BGS when you want subgrades or are chasing a Black Label. The sales data is the argument. On the cosmic foil Soul Stone, a PSA 10 brought $35,000 (Dec 19, 2025) and a BGS 9.5 brought $32,130 (May 18, 2026), but a CGC Pristine 10 brought $60,000 (June 21, 2026), because Pristine is a grade above a normal 10 and the listing put the population at three. On Smaug, the PSA 10 brought $53,499.69 while two BGS 9.5s brought $27,450 and $18,910 within a month of it. Misprint's Feb 9, 2026 comparison estimates that PSA slabs sell for roughly 15 to 25 percent more than a competitor's holder at the same grade on vintage; that is Misprint's estimate, not published sales data, and I would treat the direction as right and the number as soft. CGC is the cheapest open tier at $17 to $20 and labels misprints and errors on the slab, which matters if the card's value is the error. BGS subgrades are useful on a borderline card: a 9.5 with four strong subgrades can beat a PSA 9, and Beckett's 10 Black Label is the rarest designation in the hobby, but Beckett's budget tiers have been paused for most of the time since August 2026.

Whichever slab comes back, it should not live in a shoebox. A PSA slab fits the CardBlx PSA Case, a slab kept in a GradedGuard bumper fits the CardBlx GradedGuard Case, and both go on the CardBlx Display Stand. The general guide is at how to display graded cards, and the full range is in graded card display cases.

This post is refreshed twice a year, or sooner if PSA reopens its Value tiers.

Magic: The Gathering is a trademark of Wizards of the Coast. CardBlx is an independent brand and is not affiliated with Wizards of the Coast.